Oliver age 10 from Neath
I thoroughly enjoyed this book full of myth and welsh legend and really believable characters. It really made me think and feel it was me in the caves under Wales. I liked Hanes and how he guided Rob to become Hiraeth and Celtaidd. Why did it have to end? How soon before book 2 so we can find out what happens next? where are the tears? I want to find one! I think mum missed the clues!!